101 Best Pennsylvania Auto Insurance Companies and Startups

December 31, 2021
Top Companies (Navigation) show

This article showcases our top picks for the best Pennsylvania based Auto Insurance companies. These startups and companies are taking a variety of approaches to innovating the Auto Insurance industry, but are all exceptional companies well worth a follow.

We tried to pick companies across the size spectrum from cutting edge startups to established brands.

We selected these startups and companies for exceptional performance in one of these categories:

  • Innovation
    • Innovative ideas
    • Innovative route to market
    • Innovative product
  • Growth
    • Exceptional growth
    • Exceptional growth strategy
  • Management
  • Societal impact

[adace-ad id=”7108″]

Top Pennsylvania Auto Insurance Startups

Data sourced from Crunchbase and SemRush.

Todd Shimko Insurance Agency

Todd Shimko Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Todd Shimko Insurance Agency is an independent full service insurance agency that offers commercial and residential insurances.

Daily Underwriters of America

Daily Underwriters of America

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Daily Underwriters of America specializes in offering an extensive range of trucking insurance products and services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Colaizzo Thompson Insurance Associates

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Colaizzo Thompson Insurance Associates offers quality insurance services like auto/car insurance, homeowners insurance, and life insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

TRX Insurance Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

TRX Insurance Services is an insurance brokerage firm that offers taxi, paratransit, limo and ambulance insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Gary Pearce: Allstate Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Auto Insurance in Philadelphia, PA

Daily Underwriters of America

Rupp & Fiore Insurance Management

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Rupp & Fiore Insurance Management provides insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Yingling Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Yingling Insurance Agency offers personal, home, auto & life insurance coverage options with quality service that meets the client’s needs.

Daily Underwriters of America

AdvanBen

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

AdvanBen is an insurance agency that provides life, medical, accident, pet, auto and home insurance services to individuals and businesses.

Daily Underwriters of America

Longley Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Longley Insurance Agency offers commercial, home and auto insurance, Library coverage and volunteer fire department coverage services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Gannon Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Gannon Insurance Agency is a provider of personal and business insurance products.

Daily Underwriters of America

BCF Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

BCF Group provides personal, home, auto, flood, business, commercial property, crime, umbrella insurance and employee benefits services.

Daily Underwriters of America

American Protection Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

American Protection Insurance offers personal, auto, business and homeowner insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Triangle Benefit Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Triangle Benefit Services is an insurance service company. It is specialized in automotive insurance, business liability, and more.

Daily Underwriters of America

EF Butz Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

E F Butz Agency provides commercial, life, business, auto and personal insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Beels Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Beels Insurance offers an array of personal and commercial insurance products along with claim support services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Kattan-Ferretti Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Kattan-Ferretti Insurance offers insurance products and services that meet both businesses and individuals.

Daily Underwriters of America

Moore Tire Service

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Moore Tire Service is a family-owned automotive service center providing tire sales, preventive maintenance.

Daily Underwriters of America

Calle Financial Network

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Calle Financial Network is a financial service company.

Daily Underwriters of America

Skyrmes Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Skyrmes Insurance specializes in auto/car insurance, homeowners insurance, business/commercial insurance, and life insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

Gdula Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Gdula Insurance Agency that provides auto, home, property, business, life, health and pet insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Nicklas Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Nicklas Insurance is an independent insurance agency.

Daily Underwriters of America

J.S. Smith Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

J.S. Smith Insurance Agency provides commercial, business, personal, home, life and auto insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

David R Kalchthaler Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

David R Kalchthaler Insurance Agency provides all lines of insurance clients with the service they deserve at a premium they expect.

Daily Underwriters of America

Dietz & Bluett Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Dietz & Bluett Insurance offers cost-effective home, health, business and auto insurance solutions to individuals and businesses.

Daily Underwriters of America

Defurio Mongell & Associates

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

DeFurio Mongell & Associates is an independent insurance agency specializing in business & commercial insurance, and auto insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

CW Howard Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

CW Howard Insurance Agency is an Independent insurance agency we aren’t bound by one insurance company.

Daily Underwriters of America

National Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

National Insurance Agency provides insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Quinn Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Quinn Insurance Agency provides affordable insurance services that meets the current needs of the customers.

Daily Underwriters of America

Ridge Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Ridge Insurance Agency provides a wide range of personal and business insurance options to give you peace of mind for your house and auto.

Daily Underwriters of America

Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Preston & Grafton Insurance Agency offers employee benefits, auto, home, business, life and health insurance, along with claim services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Mosholder Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Mosholder Insurance Agency provides complete insurance services and support along with friendly customer service and professionalism.

Daily Underwriters of America

McKeighan Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

McKeighan Insurance Agency mainly focuses on offering services for vehicle, business, life and property insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

First National Financial Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

First National Financial Services offers a comprehensive range of personal and business insurance products at competitive prices.

Daily Underwriters of America

Matson Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Matson insurance is a family owned and operated commercial insurance brokerage firm serving western Pennsylvania.

Daily Underwriters of America

Century Advisory Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Century Advisory is a full-service independent financial services firm that specializes in Insurance, Retirement Planning & Tax Planning.

Daily Underwriters of America

Sprowls Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Sprowls Insurance Group offers a comprehensive range of home, auto, life, and business insurance products to its customers.

Daily Underwriters of America

Andre Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Andre Insurance Agency provides home, auto, life and business insurances.

Daily Underwriters of America

The Dreher Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

The Dreher Agency specializes in auto, life, home, farm, personal, commercial insurance and employee benefits services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Ken Pollock Auto Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Ken Pollock Auto Group provides new and used vehicles along with financing, insurance, and maintenance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Susquehanna Motorsports

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Susquehanna Motorsports is a warehousing distributor for Hella USA, SPARCO, Hankook Competition Tires, Team Dynamic Wheels.

Daily Underwriters of America

Stoskel Insurance Associates

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Stoskel Insurance Associates provides an array of personal and business insurance products and services along with claim services.

Daily Underwriters of America

ADM Marketing

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

ADM Marketing offers automotive finance and insurance products.

Daily Underwriters of America

Navage Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Navage Insurance Group offers a wide range of insurance products & services within the property, home, auto, and general liability coverage.

Daily Underwriters of America

Alcose Credit Union

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Alcose Credit Union serves financial needs through mobile banking, counseling, notary, insurance, loans and overdraft services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Heffers Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Heffers Insurance Agency is a provider of insurance coverage that includes auto, home, commercial, health, life, and flood insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

Sidney Sacks Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Sidney Sacks Agency is an insurance company that provides home, auto, business, life, and health insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Dinnin & Parkins Associates

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Dinnin & Parkins Associates a regional office of Keystone Insurers Group,

Daily Underwriters of America

Fanelli – Harley – Harper & Associates

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Fanelli, Harley, Harper & Associates is an independent insurance agency servicing a one-stop source for all Insurance needs.

Daily Underwriters of America

Lehman Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Lehman Insurance Agency, Inc. is a family owned business that was started by Keith Lehman in 1968.

Daily Underwriters of America

Digiacomo and Associates

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Digiacomo and Associates provide a range of home, life, health, auto and business insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Sitter Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Sitter Insurance specializes in business and personal insurance such as home, auto, umbrella, commercial property and advisory services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance offers business, life, health, auto, property, flood, homeowners, group benefits & disability insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

The Lowa Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

The Lowa Group provides auto, home, life, health, commercial and business insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Hockley & O’Donnell Insurance Agency, LLC

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Hockley & O’Donnell Insurance Agency, LL

Daily Underwriters of America

Comprehensive Auto Resource Company

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Comprehensive Auto Resource Company provides key replacement, GAP, total loss, auto value, tire and wheel protection services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Commonwealth Insurance Advantage

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Commonwealth Insurance Advantage offers worker’s compensation, professional liability, commercial auto, and property management services.

Daily Underwriters of America

The Stewardship Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

The Stewardship Group provides workers compensation, business owners, life, senior health, home, auto, church & ministry insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Sholley Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Sholley Insurance Agency offers complete insurance services including home, auto, rental, commercial property, flood insurance and advisory.

Daily Underwriters of America

Gilmartin Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Gilmartin Insurance Agency offers auto insurance, business insurance, homeowners insurance and specialty insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Berlanco Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Berlanco Insurance Agency represents major insurance carriers such as Erie Insurance Group, Progressive, Foremost, and others.

Daily Underwriters of America

Reagle Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Reagle Insurance is an insurance company which sells a variety of insurance products.

Daily Underwriters of America

Deibler, Straub & Troutman Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Deibler, Straub & Troutman Insurance offers products such as auto, ATV, life, medicare, RV and earthquake insurance solutions.

Daily Underwriters of America

Cosaint Insurance Partners

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Cosaint Insurance Partners is a provider of auto, home and life insurances services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Thomas McKee Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Thomas McKee Insurance Agency offers insurance services in the line of auto, life, business and property for all types of industries.

Daily Underwriters of America

Wise Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Founded in 1999 and specializing in personal lines insurance

Daily Underwriters of America

Shirley Katz

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Shirley Katz is a platform that specializes in extending its services for families and businesses seeking financial protection.

Daily Underwriters of America

Gerhart, Hartman & Ritner

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Gerhart, Hartman & Ritner is an insurance service company. It is committed to providing quality insurance products for individuals and more.

Daily Underwriters of America

Insurance Offices

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Insurance Offices is an insurance agency that provides services on auto, home, health and business insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

Meschter Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Meschter Insurance Group is an insurance agency that offers personal and business insurance, benefit and specialty scheme services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Jack L Bonus

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Jack L. Bonus offers personal and commercial insurance policies for individuals and businesses.

Daily Underwriters of America

Weber Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Weber Insurance provides coverage plans to keep businesses and families protected.

Daily Underwriters of America

Schwab Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Schwab Insurance is an insurance agency providing auto, home, personal, life, health and business insurance to clients.

Daily Underwriters of America

Joyce, Jackman and Bell Insurors

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Joyce, Jackman and Bell Insurors offers specialty commercial programs, risk management personal, business, and health insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Paul Rosko Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Paul Rosko Agency is a full-service notary and insurance agency.

Daily Underwriters of America

Ron Dunn Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Ron Dunn Agency is an insurance services provider company.

Daily Underwriters of America

Thomas M. Frick Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Frick-Ketrow Insurance Agency offers personal, auto, life and business insurance products and services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Penn Warranty

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Penn Warranty is an insurance company.

Daily Underwriters of America

McElhinny Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

McElhinny Insurance Agency provides auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, health and life insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Douple Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Douple Agency offers a wide range of home, life, health, travel, personal and business insurance products to its customers.

Daily Underwriters of America

Consumers Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Consumers Insurance Agency provides life, auto, and business insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Wolf Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Wolf Insurance agency offers home Insurance, auto Insurance, life Insurance and business Insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

Northern Insurance Specialists

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Northern Insurance Specialists offers commercial trucking and auto insurance coverages to automotive operators & fleet management companies.

Daily Underwriters of America

Capitol Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Capitol Insurance engages in motorcycle insurance and private passenger personal automobile insurance through independent agents.

Daily Underwriters of America

AAA East Central

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

AAA East Central expertise in auto, life insurance, emergency roadside assistance, employee development and customer service.

Daily Underwriters of America

Century Insurance Consultants

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Century Insurance Consultants offers auto, business, individual life and personal insurance products and services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Affiliated Insurance Service Corp

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Affiliated Insurance Service Corp is an insurance agency that provides auto insurance, home insurance, and life insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

McCollum Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

McCollum Insurance provides auto, home, life, and business insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Black Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Black Insurance Group renders worker’s compensation, general liability, renters, auto, condo, home, life and commercial insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Landis Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Landis Insurance provides financial services in the form of auto insurance, life insurance, home & business insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

The Reinard Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

The Reinard Agency renders general liability, auto, home, long-term care, home, umbrella, disability, health, and life insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Gullborg Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Gullborg Insurance offers an array of business and personal insurance products along with claim support services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Robertson Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Robertson Insurance Group specializes auto, home, life, personal and business insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Bock Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Bock Insurance Agency offers auto, home, personal, business and life insurance, along with claim support services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Finney Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Finney Insurance Agency offers home, auto, condo, life, flood, commercial property, business owners and life insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Body-Borneman Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Body-Borneman Insurance offers home, car, and business insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Harner Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Harner Insurance is a financial firm that provides auto, home, life, property and liability consulting for individuals and businesses.

Daily Underwriters of America

Neighborhood Advisors

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Neighborhood Advisors is a provider of insurance services.

Daily Underwriters of America

Christi Insurance Group

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Christi Insurance Group provides a wide range of insurance and risk management solutions for the personal commercial and marine sector.

Daily Underwriters of America

J.C. Taylor Insurance

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

J.C. Taylor Insurance is an auto insurance firm that provides antique, classic, modified, and hot rod auto insurance.

Daily Underwriters of America

Fischer Insurance Agency

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Fischer Insurance Agency offers group benefits, life, health, business, auto, home and personal insurances.

Daily Underwriters of America

Montgomery Insurance Services

Crunchbase Website Twitter Facebook Linkedin

Montgomery Insurance Services is a risk management agency that provides commercial, life, financial, home and auto insurance solutions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Don't Miss

Eric Strung: Helping Sellers Easily Sell Their House Regardless of Condition or Situation

Direct Property Buyer helps sellers easily sell their house regardless

21 Top Minnesota Leisure Companies and Startups of 2021

This article showcases our top picks for the best Minnesota